Without commenting specifically on xyzebra’s previous post, but as a law school professor, intellectual property lawyer (patent attorney) who teaches copyright law, and represents many corporate and university clients–two words: FAIR USE.
Depriving authors of the reward (or additional reward) they’re entitled to is bad (so is censorship and the use of non-public domain content). Not all clip-art, icons, and pasted doodads are public domain. Another example, while Mr. Hemmingway’s heirs may not have lost a sale (could have made some more) from scanned dust covers (perhaps used in parody) everything in life is derivative at some level. We only need to be fair.
So I agree with Gordon–just tell us how to get the content–get permission–or write a short review.
Fly safe–happy holidays–and let’s work at enjoying each others virtual company.
you are the only place on the whole entire internet that cares about this…
I think anyone who writes or publishes articles, music, software (like me), textbooks (like Airboy), etc. would disagree with you.
Looking back at your previous posts, it seems that most of them are copied articles and news items (most, if not all, copyrighted). Many are interesting and relevant, and I appreciate your bringing them to our attention. In the future, why not use links? If it can’t be linked, just let us know about it and what it’s all about.
I hope so. At least there is one place on the web I don’t mind my children going. I consider your comment a compliment to the general civility of the site.
As far as copyrights, would you let someone publish a book you wrote without asking and without compensating you? I find the ethics of the people administering this site refreshing.
As the author of an image digitizing and analysis software package that was pirated by a major european microscope manufacturer and made available for free over the internet to everyone who bought their digitizing tablets, I think the editorial practices of the folks who run this web site are totally appropriate!